Beatty v Guggenheim Exploration Co.

Modified: 17th Jun 2019
Wordcount: 305 words

Disclaimer: This is an example of a student written case summary. If you want to create an essay on any question or title, try out our AI Law Essay Writer.

Cite This

Beatty v Guggenheim Exploration Co. 225 NY 380 (1919)

Trusts Law – US – Constructive Trust – Equity – Good Faith – Duty to Employer

Facts

The defendants, Guggenheim Exploration Company, acquired and developed mining properties and the complainant, Beatty, worked for the company. There was a dispute over payment and shares of stock, which the complainant believed was compensation for his services. On the other hand, the defendant claims that this should be recoverable from the complainant. In addition, there was a dispute regarding a share of commission with Perry over a contract.

Issues

The issue in this appeal case was whether the complainant was entitled to compensation for his services or if the defendant was entitled to profits obtained as a breach of duty.

Held

It was held that the complainant could only recover the compensation that was agreed by his contract of employment. There could be no recovery for the compensation received from the agreement with Perry; he had done the work for this contract and was therefore entitled to his compensation for his services. The complainant had asked Perry to inflate the price in order to gain a share. This was a breach of duty to his employer and this money would be subject to a constructive trust. The court stated that constructive trusts could arise when property was ‘acquired through duress, fraud, undue influence or mistake, or through a breach of fiduciary duty’ [442]. The conduct of Beatty was not in utmost good faith and benefitted him, which was viewed as fraud on his employer. The court stated that a constructive trust is ‘the formula through which the conscience of equity finds expression’ [386].

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below:

Generate a new AI Essay from this title with Nomikos AI

  • Free to use
  • Takes under 2 minutes
  • No registration required
  • 2:1 level work

Suggest 3 More Related Essay Titles with Nomikos AI

  • 2:1 academic standard titles
  • Instant suggestions
  • No registration required

Get Academic Help Today!

Encrypted with a 256-bit secure payment provider