R v Jones and Smith - 1976

Modified: 22nd Oct 2021
Wordcount: 307 words

Disclaimer: This is an example of a student written case summary. If you want to create an essay on any question or title, try out our AI Law Essay Writer.

Cite This

Legal Case Summary

R v Jones & Smith [1976] 1 WLR 672

Burglary – when exceeding permission to enter becomes trespass – Theft Act 1968.

Fact

The defendants, Jones and Smith, entered Smith’s father’s house and stole two television sets. At his trial, Smith said that his father had given him unreserved permission to enter the house. They were convicted of burglary and subsequently appealed.

Issues

Under s.9(1)(b) Theft Act 1968, a person commits burglary if, having entered a building or part of a building as a trespasser, they steal anything therein. The defendants’ argued that they had not entered the house as a trespasser as they had had Smith’s father’s general permission to be in the premises.

Decision / Outcome

The appeal was dismissed. A person who has general permission to enter a premises may still be a trespasser if he enters knowing he is acting in excess of the permission given or being reckless as to whether he is so acting. The court quoted from The Calgarth [1926] P 93 where Scrutton LJ said (at 110): ‘when you invite a person into your house to use the staircase you do not invite him to slide down the banisters.’ The court rejected the defendants’ argument that it did not matter what as in the defendants’ minds when they entered so long as they had permission to enter. What mattered was whether the defendant was in possession of facts which enabled him to realise he had exceeded his permission or was reckless as to whether he exceeded it. The defendants had entered the premises knowing they had exceeded the permission given. Therefore, they were trespassers.

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing style below:

Generate a new AI Essay from this title with Nomikos AI

  • Free to use
  • Takes under 2 minutes
  • No registration required
  • 2:1 level work

Suggest 3 More Related Essay Titles with Nomikos AI

  • 2:1 academic standard titles
  • Instant suggestions
  • No registration required

Get Academic Help Today!

Encrypted with a 256-bit secure payment provider